Cost per year
The price on the day is the wrong number. Put in two versions of the same thing, how long each lasts and what it costs to keep going, and see what each really costs you per year.
Try an example (made-up but typical numbers; change them to yours):
Fill in both sides to compare. Nothing you type leaves this page.
The sum ignores what your time is worth and the hassle of shopping again, both of which favour the one that lasts. It also ignores resale: good things often sell second-hand. Before buying either, try six questions.