This or that
Short, honest comparisons between the throwaway version of a thing and the one that lasts: what each costs over ten years, what wears out, and when the cheap one really is the right choice.
- Safety razor or cartridge razor?
One costs a few pounds and then a few pounds a week. The other costs more once and then pennies. - Moka pot or pod machine?
Pods are convenient and expensive per cup. A stovetop pot asks a few minutes more and costs a fraction. - Rechargeable or disposable batteries?
For things you use every week, rechargeables win quickly. For a smoke alarm, maybe not. - Fountain pen or disposable pens?
An honest one: the money is about even. The difference is in the writing, and the bin. - Cast iron or non-stick?
Non-stick is lovely for a year or two. Cast iron is awkward for a month and then lasts a lifetime. - A steel bottle or bottled water?
Where the tap water is good, buying it in plastic is one of the easiest habits to end. - A menstrual cup or disposables?
A cup costs about what a few months of disposables do, and then nothing for years. - An e-reader or paper books?
For heavy readers the e-reader wins on money and space. For everyone, the library wins on both. - A good office chair or a cheap one?
Bought new, a good chair costs several times more. Bought second-hand, it costs about the same as a string of cheap ones, and your back notices the difference every day. - Guaranteed wool socks or a multipack?
Close on money over ten years. Very different in how many socks end up in the bin. - One good knife or a knife block?
Close on money. Not close in the kitchen: most cooks use one knife from a block of six, and it is dull.
Want to compare something else? Cost per year works for anything.