| Pod machine | Moka pot | |
|---|---|---|
| Up front | A machine, often discounted | A pot, around £25–£40 |
| Per cup | A pod, tens of pence each | Ground coffee, a few pence each |
| What wears | Pumps and electronics, usually not repairable at home | A rubber gasket and a filter plate, sold as spares |
| Waste | A pod per cup | Coffee grounds, which can go in the compost |
| Time | Seconds | Five minutes on the hob |
The sum
Over 10 years, roughly: Pod machine £2,740 · Moka pot £1,030.
Assumes two cups a day: pods at about 35p against ground coffee at about 13p a cup, plus a new gasket now and then. Typical UK prices, rounded.
Open this in the cost-per-year calculator and put in your own numbers.
When the other one wins
If you drink one coffee a week, the pod machine's running cost hardly matters, though the waste still does. A plain cafetière is another good option with no parts to wear at all.
What we recommend
Bialetti Moka Express stovetop coffee makerNo pods, no electronics, no subscription; the gasket is a cheap replaceable part.
Bodum Chambord French press, 8 cupGlass, steel and a plunger: good coffee with no pods, no power and spare parts you can replace.
The longer read: Coffee at home that lasts: no pods, no capsules, nothing to throw away
More: Safety razor or cartridge razor? · Rechargeable or disposable batteries? · Fountain pen or disposable pens? · Cast iron or non-stick? · A steel bottle or bottled water? · A menstrual cup or disposables? · An e-reader or paper books? · A good office chair or a cheap one? · Guaranteed wool socks or a multipack? · One good knife or a knife block?