| Disposable pens | Fountain pen | |
|---|---|---|
| Up front | Pennies | Around £15–£25 for a good first pen |
| Ongoing | A new pen when it runs out or goes missing | Ink cartridges, or a bottle that lasts a year |
| What wears | The whole pen | Nothing much; nibs can be swapped |
| Writing | Fast and forgettable | Slower, smoother, harder to rush |
| Care | None | Flush it now and then |
The sum
Over 10 years, roughly: Disposable pens £80 · Fountain pen £80.
Assumes a pen or two a month against a few packs of cartridges a year. The sum comes out close. Typical UK prices, rounded.
Open this in the cost-per-year calculator and put in your own numbers.
When the other one wins
If you lose pens, lend them out, or need to write on carbon copies, a cheap pen is the right tool. A refillable steel ballpoint sits in between: no ink to manage, nothing thrown away.
What we recommend
LAMY Safari fountain penA sturdy refillable pen; with a converter it uses bottled ink instead of disposable cartridges.
Kaweco Classic Sport fountain penA pocket-sized fountain pen that is refilled, not thrown away, and makes slow writing a pleasure.
Zebra F-701 stainless steel penA steel-bodied ballpoint with cheap refills: the pen people carry for decades instead of losing dozens of plastic ones.
The longer read: Tools for attention and rest: paper, ink, light and a place to sit
More: Safety razor or cartridge razor? · Moka pot or pod machine? · Rechargeable or disposable batteries? · Cast iron or non-stick? · A steel bottle or bottled water? · A menstrual cup or disposables? · An e-reader or paper books? · A good office chair or a cheap one? · Guaranteed wool socks or a multipack? · One good knife or a knife block?