| Cartridge razor | Safety razor | |
|---|---|---|
| Up front | A cheap handle, often given away | A solid metal handle, around £30–£45 |
| Ongoing | Cartridges at a few pounds each | Standard double-edge blades at pennies each |
| What wears | The whole cartridge, plastic and all | Only a thin steel blade |
| Lock-in | Cartridges fit one brand's handle | Any brand of blade fits any safety razor |
| Learning | None | A week of going slowly, with no pressure |
The sum
Over 10 years, roughly: Cartridge razor £690 · Safety razor £190.
Assumes a new cartridge every two weeks against a new blade every week. Change it to how you shave. Typical UK prices, rounded.
Open this in the cost-per-year calculator and put in your own numbers.
When the other one wins
If you shave rarely, or a safety razor makes you nervous after a fair try, a cartridge razor used sparingly is fine. The worst version is the one that sits in a drawer.
What we recommend
The longer read: A bathroom with less to throw away: shaving, washing and the monthly bin bag
More: Moka pot or pod machine? · Rechargeable or disposable batteries? · Fountain pen or disposable pens? · Cast iron or non-stick? · A steel bottle or bottled water? · A menstrual cup or disposables? · An e-reader or paper books? · A good office chair or a cheap one? · Guaranteed wool socks or a multipack? · One good knife or a knife block?