Cast iron, carbon steel or stainless: the pan you buy once

Three materials outlast any non-stick pan. Here is how to choose between them, and why you may only need one.

Cast iron, carbon steel or stainless: the pan you buy once
Photo @tomcrewceramics on Unsplash

Why not non-stick

Non-stick coatings are the one part of a pan designed to wear out. Once they scratch or lose their slip, the pan is finished. Cast iron, carbon steel and stainless steel have no coating to lose, which is why people hand them down instead of throwing them away.

Cast iron: heavy, forgiving, almost indestructible

Cast iron is thick and heavy, so it heats slowly and holds heat for a long time. That makes it excellent for searing, frying and baking, and a little slow to respond when you turn the heat down.

It is seasoned with oil, which builds a naturally slick surface with use. Rust is a cosmetic problem: scrub it off, oil it, and bake it. Very few kitchen objects can be brought back like that.

Carbon steel: the restaurant pan

Carbon steel is seasoned like cast iron but is thinner and lighter, so it heats quickly and reacts fast to the flame. It is the everyday pan of many professional kitchens: eggs, vegetables, steak, all in one pan.

It starts silver and turns black as the seasoning builds. Treat it like cast iron: hot water, dry on the heat, a few drops of oil.

Stainless steel: no seasoning, no fuss

Stainless steel needs no seasoning and doesn't react with acidic food, so tomato sauces and wine reductions are no problem. Food sticks more readily, which is also what makes good pan sauces.

It is the easiest material to care for: soak, scrub, done. Rainbow heat marks come off with a paste of bicarbonate of soda.

Enamelled cast iron for slow cooking

A heavy enamelled pot is the fourth piece many kitchens keep for life: stews, braises, bread and soup. The enamel needs gentle heat and no metal utensils, and in return it lasts for generations.

So which one?

If you want one pan for everything and don't mind the weight, cast iron. If you cook fast and often, carbon steel. If you cook a lot of sauces and want the least care, stainless. Many people end up with one frying pan and one heavy pot, and never buy another.